Other People’s (Opinions of Other People’s) Songs: Steve Almond and “Sunday Bloody Sunday”
Tuesday, October 12th, 2010I’ve been neglecting my blog for the last month and feeling inexplicable pangs of guilt about it. I mean, why feel beholden to a blog? My neglect is a sign that my Real Life has been filled with real life!
Fortunately, I recently discovered a writer who has a lot of quirky, wild, insightful, things to say about music, so I thought I’d bring his voice into the conversation.
Steve Almond spoke at Portland’s Wordstock Festival over the weekend, as part of a panel on humor. His basic philosophy of humor is to avoid trying to be funny on purpose. Rather, his approach is to poke at what is most uncomfortable and embarrassing in his life, to explore that pain incessantly, and wait for the humor reflex to kick in, which inevitably happens as a protective instinct. Sounds like tough going, and all for a laugh!
Along with professionally mining for humor through trials of emotional self-torture, Steve is a hard-core music fan and rock critic. In his words, he is a “drooling fanatic,” and in his latest book, Rock and Roll Will Save Your Life, he writes all about the highs and lows of obsessive music fandom.
Here’s an excerpt from an interview with Steve that gets at a Big Picture question for many of us (My apologies for the saucy language. I guess it goes with the rock-and-roll territory):
What, in your fanatic opinion, are songs supposed to do?
They remind us that emotions are not an inconvenient and vaguely embarrassing aspect of the human enterprise but its central purpose. They make us feel specific things we might never have felt otherwise. Every time I listen to “Sunday Bloody Sunday,” for instance, I feel a pugnacious righteousness about the fate of the Irish people. I hear that thwacking military drumbeat and Bono starts wailing about the news he heard today and I’m basically ready to enlist in the IRA and stomp some British Protestant Imperialist Ass, hell yes, bring on the fucking bangers and mash and let’s get this McJihad started. I feel these things despite the fact that:
- a. I am not Irish
- b. I sort of hate U2
- c. The song actually advocates pacifism
I love this. I too have been completely and blissfully swept away by songs countless times. Like books, theater, or any other art form, music can make us feel more deeply and guide us into new and surprising emotional territory.
I couldn’t agree more with Drooling Steve, except for one minor caveat: I sort of LOVE U2, even though I occasionally feel that the band has been playing different versions of the same song for 30 years. But that, my fanatical friends, is the topic of a much longer conversation…
See for yourself, whether U2 holds any sway over you:
Here’s more info about Steve Almond and his writing: